2.8 Managing Your Pension: Investments, Performance and Provider

Your pension is not a savings account - it is an investment vehicle. The money paid in by you and your employer is invested in a range of assets with the goal of growing over the long term. That growth does not happen by itself. The investment choices made on your behalf, or by you directly, have a direct bearing on how much you end up with.

This chapter is for anyone with a defined contribution (DC) pension who wants to understand if their provider is genuinely working in their interest. It also covers what to do if you have lost track of old pension pots from previous employers.

Note: Defined benefit pensions are managed by the pension scheme on your behalf - members do not make individual investment decisions. This chapter focuses on DC pensions, which now cover the majority of UK private sector workers.

1. Why Your Pension Needs Your Attention

It is easy to fall into a 'set it and forget it' pattern with a pension. Contributions go in automatically, statements arrive once a year, and the numbers are large enough to feel abstract. But this passivity has a real cost.

The investment choices in your pension determine how your pot grows - and how well it is protected as you approach the point of drawing it. Staying in a default fund that does not match your risk tolerance, time horizon or retirement goals can leave a significant amount of money on the table. Conversely, taking on too much risk as you near retirement can expose years of savings to a badly timed market fall.

Regular reviews allow you to:

Ensure your risk level is appropriate for your age and how far away retirement is.
Check that your funds are performing reasonably against comparable alternatives.
Identify whether charges are eating into your returns more than they should.
Make sure your investment strategy reflects how you actually plan to take your income - as drawdown, an annuity, or lump sums.
Spot any old pension pots from previous employers that may have drifted out of view.

‍

2. Finding Your Pensions - Including Lost Ones

Your Current Workplace Pension

Your current employer's pension should be the most accessible. You will normally have an online account with your provider, or receive regular statements by post. If you are unsure which provider your employer uses, your HR department or payroll team can tell you.

Once logged in, look for sections labelled 'fund choices', 'investment options', or 'portfolio summary'. This will show you which funds your money is in and what percentage is allocated to each.

Pensions from Previous Employers

The average person changes jobs several times during their working life. Each job change can leave a pension pot behind with an old provider - often worth more than people realise. It is extremely common to lose track of these, particularly if you have moved address since leaving that employer.

The UK government's free Pension Tracing Service can help. You can search by employer name or pension provider name, and the service will provide contact details for the scheme. You then contact the scheme directly to establish what you have and obtain up- to- date statements.

The Pension Tracing Service is available at: www.gov.uk/find- pension- contact- details

How much could be out there?

Industry estimates suggest billions of pounds are held in 'lost' pension pots across the UK - money that belongs to people who have simply lost track of it after changing jobs. Even small pots from early career jobs can have grown considerably over decades of investment. It is worth spending an hour tracing any you have lost sight of.

Getting a Clear Picture of Everything

Before you can manage your pension effectively, you need to know what you have. For each pot, try to establish:

The current value.
Which funds your money is invested in.
The annual charges being deducted.
Any special features or guarantees the scheme offers.
Your nominated beneficiaries - the Expression of Wish form that tells the provider who should receive the funds if you die.

3. Understanding What You Are Invested In

Default Funds

If you have never actively chosen your pension investments, your money is almost certainly in a 'default fund' - the option your provider selects automatically for members who do not make a choice. Default funds are designed to be broadly suitable for a wide range of people, which means they are rarely optimised for any individual.

Most default funds use a 'lifestyle' or 'target date' strategy: they invest more aggressively for growth in the early years, then automatically shift towards lower- risk assets as you approach a target retirement date. This is a sensible general approach - but the target date may not match when you actually plan to retire, and the shift in strategy may not reflect how you intend to take your income.

Being in the default fund is not necessarily wrong. But it should be a conscious choice, not an oversight.

Reading Fund Documents

Every fund your pension is invested in should have a fact sheet or Key Information Document (KID). These are worth reading, even if some of the language feels technical at first. They will tell you:

The fund's objective - what it is trying to achieve, for example long- term capital growth or income generation.
The asset classes it invests in - equities (company shares), bonds (government or corporate debt), property, commodities, or a mix.
The risk rating - most providers use a scale of 1 to 7, with 1 being lowest risk (typically cash or short- term bonds) and 7 being highest (typically concentrated equity strategies).
The charges - the annual management charge (AMC) and any additional costs that reduce your returns.
Past performance - useful context, though not a reliable guide to future returns.

‍

The Main Asset Classes - A Plain- English Summary

Asset class	What it is and how it behaves
Equities (shares)	Ownership stakes in companies. Higher potential returns over the long term, but more volatile - values can fall sharply and recover over years. Suitable as the growth engine of a long- horizon pension.
Bonds (fixed income)	Loans made to governments or companies in exchange for regular interest payments. Generally lower risk than equities, though not without risk. Used to reduce volatility as retirement approaches.
Property	Investment in commercial or residential property, typically through funds rather than direct ownership. Provides diversification and some income, but can be illiquid in market stress.
Cash and money market funds	Very low risk, very low return. Preserves capital but loses value in real terms over time if inflation exceeds the interest rate. Rarely suitable as a long- term pension investment.
Multi- asset funds	Funds that invest across a mix of the above. The most common type in default pension strategies. Diversification reduces the impact of any single asset class performing badly.

‍

4. Matching Your Strategy to Your Life Stage

A widely accepted principle in pension investing is that your approach to risk should shift as you move through life. The further you are from retirement, the more risk you can afford to take - because you have time for your investments to recover from downturns. The closer you get, the more valuable capital preservation becomes.

Stage	Suggested approach
20+ years to retirement	A growth- focused strategy, weighted towards equities. Time is your greatest asset - long- term equity returns historically outperform other asset classes, and short- term volatility matters much less when you have decades ahead. Don't be put off by market dips.
10–20 years to retirement	Still primarily growth- oriented, but worth reviewing whether your fund mix remains appropriate. Begin to think about how you plan to take your income - this should increasingly inform your strategy.
5–10 years to retirement	This is when 'de- risking' becomes important. Gradually shifting some of your portfolio from equities into bonds and other lower- volatility assets helps protect what you have built from a badly timed market fall in the years just before you need the money.
At or in retirement (drawdown)	If you are taking income via drawdown, your pension pot remains invested throughout retirement. Your strategy needs to balance ongoing growth - so your pot lasts - with protection of capital. A mix of growth and income- producing assets is typical, with enough in lower- risk funds to cover several years of planned withdrawals.
At or approaching retirement (annuity)	If you plan to buy an annuity, your investments in the years before purchase should be progressively moved into assets that track annuity pricing - typically long- dated gilts and bonds. A sudden fall in bond values just before purchase can significantly reduce the annuity you can buy.

‍

The lifestyle fund timing problem

If your pension is in a lifestyle or target- date fund, check that the default retirement date matches when you actually plan to retire. A lifestyle fund targeting age 65 will begin shifting to lower- risk assets in the years approaching 65 - if you plan to retire at 60 or 68, this automatic de- risking could be happening at entirely the wrong time.

5. Understanding Charges - The Invisible Drag on Your Pension

Pension charges are one of the least visible but most impactful factors in how your pot grows. Unlike investment returns, which fluctuate, charges are taken consistently -year after year - regardless of how markets perform.

The Main Types of Charge

Charge type	What it is
Annual Management Charge (AMC)	The main ongoing cost, expressed as a percentage of your fund value per year. Deducted automatically, so it is easy to overlook. For workplace pensions, there is a government charge cap of 0.75% per year on the default fund.
Total Expense Ratio (TER) / Ongoing Charges Figure (OCF)	A broader measure that includes the AMC plus any additional costs within the fund itself. Always compare OCFs rather than AMC alone.
Transaction costs	The costs incurred by the fund manager when buying and selling investments. These are disclosed separately and can add to the total cost.
Platform or administration charges	Some providers charge a flat annual fee or a percentage for running your account, separate from the fund charge itself.
Exit or transfer charges	Fees for moving your pension to a different provider. Not all schemes charge these, but worth checking before initiating a transfer.

‍

Why Even Small Differences in Charges Matter

The impact of charges compounds over time in the same way that investment returns do - but working against you. Consider two pensions both growing at 5% per year: one charging 0.5% annually, one charging 1.5%. Over 25 years on a £100,000 pot, the difference in outcome runs to tens of thousands of pounds.

As a general benchmark: a total annual cost (including all fund charges) of around 0.5% to 1.0% is reasonable for most DC pension arrangements. Much above 1.5% warrants scrutiny. Some older personal pension plans - particularly those taken out before the early 2000s - can have charges in excess of 2%, which significantly erodes returns over time.

Checking your charges

Your annual pension statement should show the charges deducted in the year. Your fund's Key Information Document will show the Ongoing Charges Figure. If you cannot find this information easily, contact your provider directly and ask them to confirm the total annual cost as a percentage of your fund.

6. Reviewing Investment Performance

Checking how your funds have performed is a sensible part of an annual review - but it needs to be done in the right way to be meaningful.

Compare Against a Relevant Benchmark

A fund's absolute return tells you little on its own. What matters is how it has performed relative to:

Its stated objective - a fund aiming for long- term growth that has consistently underperformed equity markets warrants scrutiny.
Comparable funds - how has a similar fund from a different provider performed over the same period?
A relevant index - many funds aim to track or outperform a market index such as the FTSE All- World or FTSE 100. If an actively managed fund consistently underperforms the index it benchmarks against, you may be paying higher charges for inferior results.

‍

Take a Long View

One bad year is rarely a reason to switch funds. Short- term performance is heavily influenced by market conditions that affect all funds similarly - moving out of a fund after a poor year often means crystallising a loss just before a recovery. Look at performance over five and ten years where available, not just the most recent twelve months.

When Poor Performance Is Worth Acting On

Consistent underperformance over three to five years, compared to relevant benchmarks and comparable funds, is a more meaningful signal. So is discovering that charges are significantly higher than alternatives offering similar performance. In either case, it is worth considering a switch - but take the time to understand whether there is a good reason for the underperformance before acting.

7. Assessing Your Pension Provider

Your pension provider is not just a custodian of your money - they are responsible for the quality of your investment options, the transparency of their charges, the reliability of their service, and the quality of information and tools they provide. It is worth periodically asking whether they are doing a good job.

What a Good Provider Looks Like

Clear, accessible online account with up- to- date valuations and transaction history.
A reasonable range of fund options - not just one or two default choices.
Transparent, clearly disclosed charges with no hidden fees.
Responsive customer service - accessible by phone, online or in writing.
Flexible income options when you approach retirement - drawdown, annuity purchase, UFPLS, or a combination.
A well- communicated investment approach for their default fund, with clear information about how it will change as you near retirement.
Regulatory standing - all UK pension providers must be authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). You can check a provider's status at register.fca.org.uk.

‍

Red Flags to Watch For

Difficulty accessing your account, obtaining statements, or getting clear answers from customer service.
Charges that are hard to find or not clearly explained in annual communications.
Very limited investment options, or a default fund that has not been reviewed or updated in many years.
No flexibility in how you can take income at retirement - for example, if they only offer annuity purchase and cannot facilitate drawdown.
Poor or inconsistent communication about significant fund changes.

‍

Older personal pension plans - worth a closer look

Personal pension plans taken out before the mid- 2000s sometimes have structures that are less competitive today: higher charges, with- profits funds whose bonus rates have fallen, or limited flexibility at the point of taking income. If you have an old plan you haven't reviewed in years, it is worth dusting it off. The charges and options may have moved significantly out of step with the market - though check carefully for any guaranteed benefits before deciding to transfer (see Chapter 3.5).

8. Making Changes to Your Investments

If your review leads you to decide that a change is needed - whether that is switching funds within your existing pension, or transferring to a different provider - the process is generally straightforward, though the details vary by provider.

Switching Funds Within Your Existing Pension

Most providers allow you to switch between their available funds through your online account. You will typically be able to:

Redirect future contributions to a different fund.
Switch your existing pot (or part of it) to a new fund - sometimes called a 'fund switch' or 'rebalance'.

‍

Before making any switch, read the fund's Key Information Document carefully. Consider a blended approach - you do not have to put everything into a single fund. Spreading across several complementary funds can reduce the impact of any one performing badly.

Transferring to a Different Provider

If your review suggests your current provider's charges are too high, their investment options too limited, or their service inadequate, transferring to a different provider may be the right answer. See Chapter 2.6 for a full guide to the pension transfer process, including what to check before you move and how to avoid losing valuable benefits.

When to Take Professional Advice

You do not need a financial adviser to review your fund choices or read your pension statement - and for straightforward DC pensions, many people manage this confidently themselves. But professional advice is worth considering if:

Your pension pot is substantial and the stakes of a poor decision are high.
You have multiple pensions of different types and want help bringing them together into a coherent strategy.
You are within ten years of retirement and want a tailored de- risking plan.
You are unsure whether to transfer an old pension that may have valuable guaranteed benefits.

‍

9. Building a Simple Annual Review Habit

Managing a pension well does not require significant time - but it does require regularity. An annual review of around an hour is enough to stay on top of the key factors. Here is a simple checklist to work through each year:

Review area	What to check
Valuations	What is each pension currently worth? Is it growing broadly in line with what you would expect given market conditions?
Contributions	Are you contributing as much as you intend? Is your employer contributing the full amount they are committed to? Are there any salary increases that should have been reflected in contributions?
Investments	Are you still in the right funds for your stage of life? Has anything in your circumstances changed that should prompt a strategy review?
Charges	What is the total annual cost across all your pensions? Has anything changed in your provider's fee structure?
Performance	How have your funds performed over one, three and five years relative to relevant benchmarks?
Expression of Wish	Are your nominated beneficiaries up to date? Has your personal situation changed - marriage, divorce, children, bereavement - in a way that should be reflected?
Lost pensions	Have you traced all the pension pots from previous employment? Is there anything outstanding?
Retirement target	Has your planned retirement date or lifestyle changed? Does your current strategy still align with where you want to be?

‍

The RetirePlan Finance Planner

The Finance Planner is designed to be the natural home for your annual pension review. Enter each of your DC pensions in the DC Pensions module - with current value, projected growth rate and contribution amounts - and the 25-year projection will show how they are expected to develop. As your valuations change each year, updating the planner takes only a few minutes and keeps your overall retirement picture current.

‍

Back to Search