2.6 - Pension Transfers and Consolidation

Over a working life it is common to accumulate several pension pots from different employers, each sitting with a different provider. Whether to bring these together - or leave them where they are - is one of the most practical pension decisions you will face. This chapter explains how pension transfers and consolidation work, what the benefits and risks are, and what steps to follow if you decide to proceed.

1. Two Key Concepts: Transfers and Consolidation

These terms are often used interchangeably, but they describe slightly different things:

Term	What it means
Pension transfer	Moving the value of one pension to a different scheme or provider. Your old provider stops managing the pension, and you may give up certain features or benefits in the process.
Pension consolidation	Bringing multiple pensions together by transferring them into a single scheme. You can choose which pensions to combine and which to leave separate - you do not have to consolidate them all.

‍

Both involve moving pension money. The distinction is whether you are moving one pot, or pulling several together into one place.

2. Understanding Your Pension Types

How a transfer works - and whether it makes sense - depends critically on the type of pension you have. There are two main types:

Pension type	How it works
Defined contribution (DC)	The amount you receive at retirement depends on how much has been paid in and how well the invested money has performed. Most modern workplace and personal pensions are defined contribution schemes.
Defined benefit (DB)	You receive a guaranteed income based on your salary and the number of years you worked for the employer. Also called final salary or career average schemes. Common in the public sector (NHS, teaching, civil service, armed forces).

‍

The rules, risks and considerations for transferring are very different depending on which type you have. DC-to-DC transfers are generally more straightforward. DB transfers require much more caution and, in most cases, are not advisable.

3. Transferring a Defined Contribution Pension

Reasons to Consider Moving a DC Pension

You might want to transfer a defined contribution pension if:

You want to consolidate multiple pots into one place, making your pension easier to manage and track.
Your current provider charges higher fees than alternatives. Even a slightly lower annual management charge can make a meaningful difference over many years.
You want access to different investment options that your current scheme does not offer.
You want more flexibility in how you take your pension income - for example, if your current provider does not offer drawdown or flexible lump sum withdrawals.
You have changed jobs and want to move an old workplace pension to your new employer's scheme, or to a personal pension or SIPP you manage yourself.

‍

When a DC Transfer Might Not Be a Good Idea

A transfer cannot normally be undone. Before proceeding, always check whether your existing pension has features or guarantees you would lose by moving:

Exit fees or penalties for leaving.
Guaranteed annuity rates - the right to convert your pot into a guaranteed income at a rate that may be significantly better than anything available on the open market today.
With-profits bonuses - an extra payment due after a certain date that you would forfeit by leaving early.
A protected normal minimum pension age - some older schemes allow access from age 55 even after the general minimum pension age rises to 57 in April 2028.

It may also make sense to leave a pension where it is if:

Your employer currently contributes to it. Many employers will not pay contributions into a different scheme, so transferring could mean losing ongoing employer contributions.
The pot is worth less than £10,000 and you plan to take it all at once. Small pot rules allow you to take the full amount with 25% tax-free without reducing your annual allowance or lump sum allowance - a useful flexibility worth preserving.

The key rule: always check before you move
A pension transfer usually cannot be undone. Never rush into a decision. Always ask your existing provider whether there are exit fees, guaranteed benefits, or protected ages that would be lost by transferring out.
(Source: MoneyHelper - Should I transfer or combine my pensions?)

‍

How to Transfer a DC Pension: Step by Step‍

You would usually follow the following process for a DC pension transfer:

Step	What to do
1. Confirm your pension type	Make sure you are dealing with a defined contribution pension. If you are unsure, ask your provider.
2. Check for benefits you would lose	Ask your provider about exit fees, guaranteed annuity rates, with-profits bonuses and any protected pension ages.
3. Decide where to transfer to	Compare your existing schemes or research new providers. Consider fees, investment options, withdrawal flexibility and ease of administration.
4. Get a transfer value	Ask your existing provider for a transfer value - how much the new scheme would receive. This can rise or fall until the transfer is completed.
5. Consider financial advice	A regulated adviser can tell you whether you would be better off transferring and recommend suitable schemes. Advice may be mandatory in some cases (see below).
6. Initiate the transfer	Ask the new scheme to start the transfer. They will usually provide a form and contact your existing provider directly. Transfers typically take 2–6 weeks, though providers have up to 6 months.

‍

Once transferred, your money will usually be invested in the new scheme's default fund unless you choose otherwise.

4. Transferring a Defined Benefit Pension

Start with this: most people are better off keeping a DB pension
The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) and the Pensions Regulator (TPR) both advise that most people are better off keeping a defined benefit pension. Transferring out means giving up a guaranteed income for life that cannot be recovered once surrendered.
(Source: MoneyHelper - How to transfer out of a defined benefit pension)

What You Would Be Giving Up

A defined benefit pension offers guarantees that a defined contribution scheme cannot replicate:

A guaranteed income for life, regardless of how investment markets perform.
Annual increases to your pension income, protecting its value against inflation.
Death benefits - a portion of your pension income continuing to your dependants after you die, typically until a partner's death or children reach adulthood.
No investment charges - DB scheme members do not pay fees from their pension pot.

‍

Reasons You Might Still Consider Transferring Out

Despite the strong case for staying, there are some circumstances where a DB transfer could be appropriate - for example:

You have a short life expectancy and no dependants, and would receive more total money by taking a lump sum from a DC scheme than from a guaranteed income stream that stops on death.
You want more flexibility in how and when you access your money - including multiple lump sums or early access in ways your DB scheme does not permit.
You want to change how your pension is inherited - money remaining in a DC scheme can generally be left to anyone you nominate, whereas a DB scheme typically pays only to dependants.
You want to consolidate multiple DB pensions together - this is a DB-to-DB transfer and carries different considerations.

‍

Even where these factors apply, the decision should be made carefully and with professional guidance. The guaranteed income given up is almost always substantial.

‍

The Mandatory Advice Requirement

If your defined benefit pension is worth more than £30,000, you are legally required to obtain regulated financial advice before you are permitted to transfer it to a defined contribution scheme. This advice can often cost several thousand pounds. If your employer has offered you an incentive to transfer, they are required to meet the cost of the advice.

Abridged advice may be available at lower cost and will tell you whether a transfer is clearly unsuitable - but you would need full advice before a positive recommendation or to proceed with a transfer.

‍

Restrictions on DB Transfers

Not all DB schemes allow transfers out. You may not be able to transfer if:

Your pension has already started paying out.
You are within one year of your normal retirement date under the scheme rules.
You are a member of an unfunded public sector scheme - such as the NHS, Teachers', or Armed Forces Pension Schemes. These schemes typically do not allow transfers to defined contribution arrangements.

‍

How to Transfer a DB Pension: Step by Step

Step	What to do
1. Confirm the type of transfer	This guide covers DB-to-DC transfers. For DB-to-DB transfers, different rules apply.
2. Understand what you are giving up	Review your guaranteed income, annual increases, death benefits and the absence of charges. These are the benefits you would surrender.
3. Check your scheme allows transfers out	Ask your provider whether a transfer out is permitted under the scheme rules.
4. Request a Cash Equivalent Transfer Value (CETV)	Ask your provider for the CETV - the amount the new scheme would receive. A CETV is usually valid for three months. Your provider has up to three months to provide it. There may be a charge if you request more than one in a 12-month period.
5. Get regulated financial advice (mandatory if pot > £30,000)	Find a regulated adviser before requesting your CETV if possible, to avoid the value expiring before advice is received.
6. Compare what the new scheme would offer	Give the CETV to the new scheme or your adviser and ask for projections of what retirement income it could provide, alongside the charges and investment options.
7. Confirm and complete the transfer	Complete transfer forms. Submit confirmation of financial advice if required. If your CETV has expired, request a new one. Allow 2–6 weeks for completion.

‍

5. Pension Transfer Scams - Stay Protected

Pension scams are a serious and growing problem. According to official data from Report Fraud, over £17.5 million was lost to pension scams in 2024, with an average loss of £34,000 per person - and the true figure is likely higher, as not all scams are reported.

Never transfer your pension because of a cold contact
Do not transfer your money to a new pension provider or invest any money because of a cold call, visit, email or text. It is likely a scam. You could lose your money and face a large tax bill.
(Source: MoneyHelper - Should I transfer or combine my pensions?)

‍

How Your Provider Protects You

When you request a pension transfer, your existing provider is required to carry out checks to assess whether there is a risk of a scam. They will review the type of scheme you are transferring to, how it is regulated, the fees involved, and your adviser's details if you have taken advice.

If your provider has concerns, they can:

Stop the transfer entirely if they identify serious red flags - such as the request following a cold call, the involvement of an unregulated adviser, or promises of payments or incentives to transfer.
Delay the transfer and require you to attend a free MoneyHelper Pension Safeguarding Guidance appointment before proceeding. This is offered where there are amber flag concerns - for example, unusually high charges, unregulated or overseas investments, or an unusual scheme structure.

If your transfer is stopped or delayed and you believe it is legitimate, you have the right to complain to your provider. The MoneyHelper Pension Safeguarding Guidance appointment is free, impartial and government-backed - attending one does not commit you to cancelling your transfer.

‍

6. Consolidation and the RetirePlan Finance Planner

If you have multiple pension pots, the Finance Planner in your RetirePlan app is designed to accommodate them all - whether you choose to consolidate or not. You can enter each defined contribution pension separately in the DC Pensions module, and each defined benefit pension in the DB Pensions module. The 25-year projection brings all your income sources together into a single view.

Thinking through whether to consolidate before you reach your target retirement date? The Finance Planner's what-if modelling lets you test different retirement ages and income combinations - useful context when you are weighing up whether bringing pensions together makes sense for your overall plan.

Using the Finance Planner with multiple pensions
The Finance Planner handles multiple DC and DB pensions simultaneously. As a Premium member, you can save separate named scenarios - for example, one plan with consolidated pensions and one without - and compare them side by side to see the effect on your projected retirement income.

‍

7. Summary: Key Rules and Considerations

Topic	Key point
DC pension transfer	Generally straightforward but check for exit fees, guaranteed annuity rates, with-profits bonuses and protected pension ages before proceeding.
DB pension transfer	Most people are better off staying. Transferring means permanently giving up a guaranteed income for life. The FCA and TPR both advise caution.
Mandatory advice threshold	If your DB pension is worth more than £30,000, regulated financial advice is legally required before a transfer to a DC scheme can proceed.
Cash Equivalent Transfer Value (CETV)	The sum your DB pension is worth as a lump sum for transfer purposes. Valid for 3 months; your provider has up to 3 months to issue it.
Transfer timeline	Typically 2–6 weeks; providers have up to 6 months by law.
Small pot rule	Pots under £10,000 can be taken as a full lump sum (25% tax-free) without affecting your annual allowance or lump sum allowance. Worth preserving.
Scam protection	Never transfer following a cold call or unsolicited contact. Your provider will carry out checks and can stop or delay a transfer they believe is at risk.
Public sector DB schemes	Unfunded schemes (NHS, Teachers', Armed Forces) typically do not allow transfers to DC arrangements.

‍

8. When to Seek Professional Advice

You should consider taking regulated financial advice before transferring any pension if:

Your defined benefit pension is worth more than £30,000 - advice is legally required in this case.
Your existing pension has guaranteed annuity rates or other special features whose value is not immediately obvious.
You are unsure whether a transfer would leave you better or worse off overall.
You are approaching retirement and want to understand the full picture before making an irreversible decision.
You have received any unsolicited contact encouraging you to transfer.

A regulated financial adviser can assess whether a transfer makes sense for your personal circumstances, recommend suitable schemes, and help you identify whether a proposed arrangement is legitimate. For step-by-step guidance, MoneyHelper also provides free, impartial help at moneyhelper.org.uk.

RetirePlan Adviser Search

If you are considering a pension transfer - particularly from a defined benefit scheme - speaking with a regulated financial adviser is strongly recommended. The RetirePlan Adviser Search can help you find a qualified, regulated adviser in your area.

‍

Sources quoted in this guide: MoneyHelper (UK Government Source), Open Government Licence v3.0.

Back to Search